One of my favorite summer road trip snacks has always been a bagel dog, which, if you’re not familiar, is a hot dog wrapped in bagel dough. Nowadays, instead of hitting the road, I reach for the freezer. Once you’ve enjoyed a Nathan’s bagel dog in the air fryer you’ll be hooked!
Nathans, the famous hot dog company, happens to make versions of their popular restaurant fare available in the freezer section of your local grocery store. These bagel dogs are amazing, though a Nathan’s Pretzel Dog in the Air Fryer is equally delicious!
The appeal here is that you no longer have to venture to the mall or the Boardwalk to get your hands on this Coney Island style fare. Instead, the air fryer delivers that perfect level of browning and a juicy hot dog in under 10 minutes!
Serve them up as a snack, or a meal when paired with some other sides, like onion rings, fries, chips, or my personal favorite, mac and cheese! Don’t forget the ketchup or mustard for dipping too!
Ingredients List
16 ounce box frozen Nathan’s bagel dogs (4 count)
Ingredient Tips and Notes
Each box used to be 20 ounces (5 count) but has been reduced to 16 ounce and 4 count as of lately. If you want a larger quantity, you can try Costco, Sam’s Club, or another wholesale store
Currently, Nathan’s only makes full sized frozen bagel dogs with everything bagel seasoning on top (yes, it does have caraway seeds if that helps your decision). For plain, you’ll want to seek out their mini bagel dogs instead (which are a great appetizer option)!
Though this recipe is for Nathan’s brand, it does work for other brands as well. For example, Vienna Beef bagel dogs work just as well!
Nathan’s Bagel Dog Air Fryer Instructions
Remove the bagel dogs from all packaging and place into your air fryer’s basket or rack in a single layer. Tip: I usually put them topping side down to start
Cook on the air fry setting at 370°F (or 375°F depending on your air fryer’s available settings) for 8-10 minutes, pausing halfway through to flip them over
Bagel dogs are ready when they are browned to your liking and the internal temperature reaches 165°F (per Nathan’s directions)
Serve hot with your favorite condiments and sides!
What to Serve With Bagel Dogs
French fries
Potato chips
Mac and cheese
Baked beans
Chili
Glazed carrots
Coleslaw
Fried pickles
Potato salad
Fruit salad
Condiments
Cold beer
Soda
Lemonade
Iced tea
There are a variety of different sides and drinks you can pair with bagel dogs to complete the meal. Find the mix of kid friendly to adult approved that works best for you!
Yes, you can cook Nathan’s bagel dogs in an air fryer. They can be cooked directly from frozen, with no defrosting required.
The air fryer delivers warm dough with a crispy exterior, and browns the ends of the hot dog as well.
What Is a Nathan’s Bagel Dog?
A Nathan’s bagel dog is a delicious combination of a hot dog wrapped in soft, chewy bagel dough.
They are available in the frozen foods section of most major grocery stores.
Can I Cook Nathan’s Bagel Dogs from Frozen in the Air Fryer?
Yes, you can cook Nathan’s bagel dogs directly from frozen in the air fryer without thawing.
To help with the moisture, either preheat your air fryer, or flip the dogs once during cooking.
What Temperature and Cooking Time Should I Use for Air Frying Nathan’s Bagel Dogs?
Preheat the air fryer to around 370-380°F and cook the Nathan’s bagel dogs for approximately 8-11 minutes, flipping halfway through the cooking process for even browning.
Cooking times can vary between individual air fryers, so adjust in small increments as needed to achieve the desired level of browning.
Can I Add Toppings or Condiments to Nathan’s Bagel Dogs Before Air Frying Them?
Since they are already assembled and frozen, it is difficult to add toppings or condiments prior to air frying. Additionally, they may burn or over crisp during cooking.
It is recommended to instead add toppings like cheese or condiments after cooking for best results.
Can I Cook Multiple Nathan’s Bagel Dogs at Once in the Air Fryer?
Yes, you can cook multiple Nathan’s bagel dogs at once in the air fryer, as long as they fit comfortably in a single layer in the basket without overcrowding.
Cooking time will not change for multiples, so long as there is ample space, including some air space between dogs to allow for air circulation.
Recipe Pro Tips
The flip is important if you are not preheating your air fryer, as this helps prevent cold spots from forming as it thaws. If you are worried about losing toppings, simply preheat the air fryer ahead of time and then you don’t need to flip them!
I cooked my bagel dogs in a Ninja air fryer without preheating and they were perfect after 10 minutes (verified via thermometer). If you do preheat, lower by 2 minutes to start. Other air fryers will vary slightly in terms of required time
Some of my frozen bagel dogs were broken in the box (which was not damaged at all). It likely won’t happen to everyone, but if you want them looking very nice, I suggest picking up some extras (just from personal experience)
Storage and Reheating Tips
Store any leftover Nathan’s bagel dogs in the refrigerator for 3-4 days. I do not recommend refreezing them after cooking once (it starts to affect temperature and moisture levels)
To reheat a bagel dog, air fry at 350°F for 3-5 minutes, until warmed through. You can also microwave for about a minute (preferably cut in half) but you’ll lose the crispy exterior to the bagel crust
These Nathan’s bagel dogs in the air fryer are the perfect snack or light meal. They go from frozen to fantastic in under 10 minutes!
Similar to their pretzel dogs, these bagel dogs are wrapped in pillowy dough that gets just the right amount of crisp in the air fryer. Add that to the caramelized all beef hot dog ends, and it’s a delicious bite!
I like to pair mine with mac and cheese (it’s a classic) but there are lots of other great side dish options to please the whole family and make it a meal.
If you don’t like the everything bagel seasoning on top, try out the mini bagel dogs (which are plain), or a different brand, like Vienna all beef bagel dogs. They’re equally tasty!
Nathan’s Bagel Dog Air Fryer Recipe
Cook up a delicious Nathan’s frozen bagel dog in your air fryer in 10 minutes or less! They come out warm, toasted, and caramelized on the ends for a perfect snack or meal.
16Ouncebox frozen Nathan's Famous Coney Island bagel dogs(4 count)
Instructions
Remove the bagel dogs from all packaging and place into your air fryer’s basket or rack in a single layer. Tip: I usually put them topping side down to start
16 Ounce box frozen Nathan's Famous Coney Island bagel dogs
Cook on the air fry setting at 370°F (or 375°F depending on your air fryer’s available settings) for 8-10 minutes, pausing halfway through to flip them over
Bagel dogs are ready when they are browned to your liking and the internal temperature reaches 165°F (per Nathan’s guidelines)
Serve hot with your favorite condiments and sides!
Notes
Each box used to be 20 ounces (5 count) but has been reduced to 16 ounce and 4 count as of lately. If you want a larger quantity, you can try Costco, Sam’s Club, or another wholesale store
Currently, Nathan’s only makes full sized frozen bagel dogs with everything bagel seasoning on top. For plain, you’ll want to seek out their mini bagel dogs instead (which are a great appetizer option)!
Though this recipe is for Nathan’s brand, it does work for other brands as well. For example, Vienna Beef bagel dogs work just as well!
The flip is important if you are not preheating your air fryer, as this helps prevent cold spots from forming as it thaws. If you are worried about losing toppings, simply preheat the air fryer ahead of time and then you don’t need to flip them!
I cooked my bagel dogs in a Ninja air fryer without preheating and they were perfect after 10 minutes (verified via thermometer). If you do preheat, lower by 2 minutes to start. Other air fryers will vary slightly in terms of required time
Some of my frozen bagel dogs were broken in the box (which was not damaged at all). It likely won’t happen to everyone, but if you want them looking very nice, I suggest picking up some extras (just from personal experience)
Store any leftover Nathan’s bagel dogs in the refrigerator for 3-4 days. I do not recommend refreezing them after cooking once (it starts to affect temperature and moisture levels)
To reheat a bagel dog, air fry at 350°F for 3-5 minutes, until warmed through. You can also microwave for about a minute (preferably cut in half) but you’ll lose the crispy exterior to the bagel crust
Exact nutritional values will vary based on flavor of ingredients, any condiments or sides added, and quantity consumed, so please consider this a guideline only
Keyword bagel dogs in air fryer, coney island bagel dogs, frozen bagel dogs, how to cook bagel dogs in air fryer, nathan’s bagel dog, nathan’s bagel dog air fryer, nathan’s bagel dog air fryer instructions, quick and convenient snack, simple dinner ideas
I enjoy trying new recipes, creating my own, and dabbling with new techniques all the time. My husband loves to protest when I make him my guinea pig, but it’s all for the love of food!
My cooking philosophy is that great tasting food doesn't have to be complicated or time consuming to make. I'm a home cook with over 20 years of experience feeding myself and others. I've learned from a variety of different people, things I've learned online, and some trial and error as well.
I enjoy cooking a variety of foods, from convenience to comfort foods, as well as international cuisine. You can rest assured that all of my recipes have been actually made, thoroughly tested, and most importantly: tasted! I want you to enjoy my food as much as I do!
